Mailbag: Proposal One

Received a constituent email today asking about Proposal 1 on the August primary ballot.  I’m sharing my response for the many who are also confused or looking for direction on this curiously-worded proposal.

Q:  Do you support Prop 1?

A:  The short answer to your question is yes, though reluctantly.

The ballot initiative codifies a replacement for the Personal Property Tax (PPT) which was previously eliminated by the Legislature a few years back but with no replacement for the roughly $500 million per year that went mainly to funding local units of government ans schools.  The PPT is accurately characterized as a disincentivefor investment in Michigan and getting rid of it is good for business and hopefully will free up resources to prompt job creation.  The ballot proposal would set in place revenue streams to keep local units of government “whole,” avoiding cuts that would have been devastating.

That said, under Gov. Rick Snyder business has already received a $1.8 billion tax cut as well as many other considerations, yet the state has not seen the job growth promised.  Also, as the ballot proposal does not create a “money tree,” the revenue to protect local governments has to come from somewhere.  This impact to the state’s General Fund is being downplayed by proponents but according to the non-partisan Citizen’s Research Council of Michigan, “The tax shift will have significant fiscal implications for the state’s General Fund . . . revenues will be $107 million lower in FY2016 and $349 million lower in FY2017 as more and more state revenue is shifted to the new local tax. By FY2025, the GF/GP revenue loss is expected to reach $500 million.”

What will be the effect?  The General Fund in FY 2013 was $9.2 billion of which 88% goes toward funding human services and 12% to state departments.  Specifically, human services includes $1.96 billion for Corrections (the state prison system), $2.7 billion for Community Health programs, and $1.2 billion for Higher Education and Community Colleges, to name just a few of thee big ones.  So, absent any changes or enhancements, all of these will see about a 5% cut within three years to pay for this tax cut.

Defeating this ballot initiative wouldn’t change the fact that Lansing has already repealed the PPT.  (NOTE:  I received a correction from a knowledgeable source indicating that if the ballot measure goes down, the old PPT provisions would stand.)  This revenue replacement scheme is likely to be the best deal offered [from a regime bent on cutting business taxes at whatever cost], though when the cuts come and services are impacted in the form of prison overcrowding, higher tuition for students, and reduced services for elderly, poor, and disabled, most will have no doubt forgotten about the trade off we’re making in August 2014.

Lastly, the partisan in me is standing with my team.  Mark Schauer, my candiate for Michigan Governor, has endorsed this proposal as well.  If it’s good enough for the next Governor of Michigan . . .

I welcome your thoughts as well.  In the meantime, know that I appreciate hearing from you and hope you’ll call on me if I can ever be of service.

For a lot more detail on the proposal, visit the Citizens Research Council website here.  For info about the state budget, visit the House Fiscal Agency report here.

(325) Comments

  1. Pingback: sildenafil generic

  2. Pingback: erection pills viagra online

  3. Pingback: best ed pills online

  4. Pingback: ed meds online without doctor prescription

  5. Pingback: cialis generic

  6. Pingback: walmart pharmacy

  7. Pingback: canadian online pharmacy

  8. Pingback: Buy cialis online

  9. Pingback: cialis mastercard

  10. Pingback: vardenafil 20mg

  11. Pingback: levitra 20 mg

  12. Pingback: levitra coupon

  13. Pingback: best online casinos that payout

  14. Pingback: play casino online

  15. Pingback: viagra no prescription

  16. Pingback: real money online casino

  17. Pingback: casino slots

  18. Pingback: tadalafil vs sildenafil

  19. Pingback: cash advance

  20. Pingback: loan online

  21. Pingback: online loans

  22. Pingback: viagra 100mg

  23. Pingback: best real money casinos

  24. Pingback: best real money online casinos

  25. Pingback: 5 mg cialis

  26. Pingback: real money olnine casinos

  27. Pingback: real money casino games

  28. Pingback: renate

  29. Pingback: cialis 20

  30. Pingback: cialis to buy

  31. Pingback: cialis generic

  32. Pingback: generic for cialis

  33. Pingback: golden nugget online casino

  34. Pingback: casino games online

  35. Pingback: online casino games

  36. Pingback: best online casino for money

  37. Pingback: viagra pills

  38. Pingback: herbal viagra

  39. Pingback: viagra for women

  40. Pingback: cialis coupon

  41. Pingback: purchasing cialis online

  42. Pingback: casino gambling

  43. Pingback: gambling casino

  44. Pingback:

  45. Pingback: lowest price for viagra 100mg

  46. Pingback: cialis 20 mg

  47. Pingback: Viagra 130 mg tablets

  48. Pingback: viagra tablets for men price

  49. Pingback: where can i buy Cialis 80mg

  50. Pingback: antivert 25mg otc

  51. Pingback: catapres 100 mcg online

  52. Pingback: ceclor 500mg nz

  53. Pingback: ceftin 500mg pharmacy

  54. Pingback: celebrex canada

  55. Pingback: celexa prices

  56. Pingback: cephalexin 500mg prices

  57. Pingback: cipro 1000mg tablets

  58. Pingback: how to buy claritin 10 mg

  59. Pingback: hollywood casino

  60. Pingback: slots online

  61. Pingback: jackpot party casino

  62. Pingback: casino moons online casino

  63. Pingback: casino online slots

  64. Pingback: parx casino online

  65. Pingback: party casino online nj

  66. Pingback: online casinos

  67. Pingback: slot machine games

  68. Pingback: best online casinos that payout

  69. Pingback: buy car insurance quotes

  70. Pingback: american car insurance quotes

  71. Pingback: state car insurance quotes

  72. Pingback: aarp car insurance

  73. Pingback: liberty car insurance quotes

  74. Pingback: car insurance quotes companies

  75. Pingback: car insurance online now

  76. Pingback: state farm car insurance quotes

  77. Pingback: car insurance quotes renewal

  78. Pingback: car insurance quotes ontario

  79. Pingback: personal loans baton rouge

  80. Pingback: no credit check payday loans

  81. Pingback: installment loans online

  82. Pingback: Buy now viagra

  83. Pingback: places to get quick loans

  84. Pingback: bad credit loans bad credit loans

  85. Pingback: payday loans denver

  86. Pingback: personal loans personal loans

  87. Pingback: cbd oil vs hemp oil comparison

  88. Pingback: cbd oil milford ohio

  89. Pingback: cbd oil for sale on amazon

  90. Pingback: does hemp oil contain cbd

  91. Pingback: best cbd oil for pain for sale

  92. Pingback: does hemp seed oil contain cbd

  93. Pingback: does walmart sell cbd oil

  94. Pingback: how much cbd oil for pain relief

  95. Pingback: reviews of cbd gummies for teens

  96. Pingback: college admission essay writing service

  97. Pingback: buy an essay online cheap

  98. Pingback: australian essay writing service

  99. Pingback: write an argument essay

  100. Pingback: how to write argument essay

  101. Pingback: buy college essays

  102. Pingback: demand assigned multiple access

  103. Pingback: online homework help

  104. Pingback: paper writer

  105. Pingback: buying an essay

  106. Pingback: cheapest cleocin

  107. Pingback: clomid 50mg canada

  108. Pingback: Best prices on viagra

  109. Pingback: how to purchase clonidine

  110. Pingback: clozaril pharmacy

  111. Pingback: where can i buy colchicine

  112. Pingback: Buy cheap viagra online us

  113. Pingback: symbicort inhaler generic

  114. Pingback: combivent 50/20mcg prices

  115. Pingback: coreg cost

  116. Pingback: compazine for sale

  117. Pingback: order coumadin 1mg

  118. Pingback: cozaar united states

  119. Pingback: crestor coupon

  120. Pingback: Canada viagra generic

  121. Pingback: how to buy cymbalta

  122. Pingback: Buy cheap viagra

  123. Pingback: dapsone 1000caps online

  124. Pingback: cost of ddavp

  125. Pingback: depakote australia

  126. Pingback: diamox 250 mg without prescription

  127. Pingback: how to purchase differin 15g

  128. Pingback: diltiazem otc

  129. Pingback: doxycycline cost

  130. Pingback: dramamine 50mg cost

  131. Pingback: where to buy elavil 25mg

  132. Pingback: erythromycin 500mg pharmacy

  133. Pingback: buy etodolac

  134. Pingback: flomax 0,4 mg without a prescription

  135. Pingback: flonase nasal spray 50 mcg over the counter

  136. Pingback: garcinia cambogia caps without prescription

  137. Pingback: geodon 80 mg otc

  138. Pingback: hyzaar over the counter

  139. Pingback: please write my essay for me

  140. Pingback: where can i buy imdur

  141. Pingback: where can i buy imitrex 100 mg

  142. Pingback: imodium 2mg purchase

  143. Pingback: click to read more

  144. Pingback: how long for viagra to work

  145. Pingback: viagra alternative

  146. Pingback: imuran 50mg tablet

  147. Pingback: indocin 75 mg without prescription

  148. Pingback: levaquin 750 mg for sale

  149. Pingback: lopid australia

  150. Pingback: lopressor cost

  151. Pingback: order luvox

  152. Pingback: macrobid 100mg pills

  153. Pingback: how to purchase meclizine

  154. Pingback: mestinon without prescription

  155. Pingback: micardis online

  156. Pingback: mobic 7,5mg for sale

  157. Pingback: motrin 200 mg generic

  158. Pingback: best online pharmacy stores

  159. Pingback: nortriptyline 25mg united states

  160. Pingback: periactin 4 mg without prescription

  161. Pingback: plaquenil over the counter

  162. Pingback: prednisolone price

  163. Pingback: order prevacid 30mg

  164. Pingback: prilosec 40 mg tablets

  165. Pingback: proair inhaler online pharmacy

  166. Pingback: procardia uk

  167. Pingback: proscar 5 mg australia

  168. Pingback: protonix tablet

  169. Pingback: provigil 100mg prices

  170. Pingback: pulmicort 100 mcg medication

  171. Pingback: pyridium 200 mg online

  172. Pingback: reglan pills

  173. Pingback: remeron united states

  174. Pingback: retin-a cream 0.025% cheap

  175. Pingback: revatio tablet

  176. Pingback: risperdal 1 mg purchase

  177. Pingback: buy robaxin 500 mg

  178. Pingback: rogaine united states

  179. Pingback: seroquel australia

  180. Pingback: how to buy singulair

  181. Pingback: skelaxin 400mg united states

  182. Pingback: spiriva 9mcg no prescription

  183. Pingback: where can i buy tenormin 25mg

  184. Pingback: where can i buy thorazine

  185. Pingback: toprol 25mg cost

  186. Pingback: tricor 160mg for sale

  187. Pingback: valtrex without a doctor prescription

  188. Pingback: vantin 100mg no prescription

  189. Pingback: verapamil 120 mg without prescription

  190. Pingback: voltaren online

  191. Pingback: wellbutrin 300mg uk

  192. Pingback: how to buy zanaflex 2mg

  193. Pingback: order zithromax 100 mg

  194. Pingback: click over here

  195. Pingback: zocor united states

  196. Pingback: zovirax tablet

  197. Pingback: buy zyloprim

  198. Pingback: zyprexa uk

  199. Pingback: zyvox tablets

  200. Pingback: where can i buy sildenafil

  201. Pingback: tadalafil 40 mg tablets

  202. Pingback: how to purchase furosemide

  203. Pingback: escitalopram 10 mg for sale

  204. Pingback: aripiprazole 20 mg tablets

  205. Pingback: pioglitazone 15 mg price

  206. Pingback: spironolactone 100 mg online

  207. Pingback: glimepiride 1 mg united kingdom

  208. Pingback: meclizine 25 mg nz

  209. Pingback: buy leflunomide

  210. Pingback: atomoxetine 18mg online pharmacy

  211. Pingback: donepezil 5mg canada

  212. Pingback: anastrozole 1mg price

  213. Pingback: irbesartan purchase

  214. Pingback: cost of dutasteride

  215. Pingback: cheap olmesartan 40 mg

  216. Pingback: buspirone without a prescription

  217. Pingback: cefuroxime 250 mg over the counter

  218. Pingback: celecoxib 200mg cheap

  219. Pingback: generic cialis

  220. Pingback: citalopram 10 mg without prescription

  221. Pingback: cephalexin 500 mg canada

  222. Pingback: ciprofloxacin 750mg cheap

  223. Pingback: loratadine 10mg pills

  224. Pingback: clindamycin uk

  225. Pingback: clozapine tablet

  226. Pingback: cheap prochlorperazine 5 mg

  227. Pingback: how to buy carvedilol

  228. Pingback: warfarin purchase

  229. Pingback: cheap rosuvastatin

  230. Pingback: divalproex 125mg coupon

  231. Pingback: order trazodone

  232. Pingback: tolterodine uk

  233. Pingback: acetazolamide united kingdom

  234. Pingback: fluconazole 50 mg purchase

  235. Pingback: phenytoin 100 mg otc

  236. Pingback: oxybutynin without a prescription

  237. Pingback: doxycycline pills

  238. Pingback: cheapest venlafaxinemg

  239. Pingback: amitriptyline no prescription

  240. Pingback: cost of erythromycin

  241. Pingback: estradiol 2mg nz

  242. Pingback: ivwkecqj

  243. Pingback: tamsulosin 0.2mg without prescription

  244. Pingback: alendronate purchase

  245. Pingback: how do i get a viagra prescription

  246. Pingback: nitrofurantoin canada

  247. Pingback: wat kost cialis in nederland

  248. Pingback: how long for ivermectin to work

  249. Pingback: glipizide 10mg australia

  250. Pingback: sumatriptan 50mg usa

  251. Pingback: loperamide united kingdom

  252. Pingback: cialis pastillas

  253. Pingback: azathioprine 50 mg cost

  254. Pingback: propranolol pills

  255. Pingback: indomethacin 50mg without a doctor prescription

  256. Pingback: terbinafine otc

  257. Pingback: order atorvastatin

  258. Pingback: amoxicillin 500mg for sale

  259. Pingback: furosemide tab 40mg

  260. Pingback: azithromycin for sale mexico

  261. Pingback: stromectol online pharmacy

  262. Pingback: albuterol purchase

  263. Pingback: gemfibrozil generic

  264. Pingback: metoprolol prices

  265. Pingback: clotrimazole 10g united states

  266. Pingback: doxycycline and magnesium

  267. Pingback: prednisolone canada

  268. Pingback: clomid vs metformin

  269. Pingback: levitra with dapoxetine

  270. Pingback: diflucan relief

  271. Pingback: synthroid problems

  272. Pingback: getting off propecia

  273. Pingback: neurontin and cymbalta

  274. Pingback: metformin acidosis

  275. Pingback: paxil high feeling

  276. Pingback: plaquenil mg

  277. Pingback: levitra printable discount coupons

  278. Pingback: cialis 200mg

  279. Pingback:

  280. Pingback: free dating sites in finland

  281. Pingback: Levitra with Dapoxetine

  282. Pingback: cheapest pharmacy for prescription drugs

  283. Pingback: what are the side effect of viagra

  284. Pingback: difference between escitalopram and fluoxetine

  285. Pingback: viagra samples

  286. Pingback: sildenafil

  287. Pingback: cost of atorvastatin

  288. Pingback: sildenafil generic

  289. Pingback: cheapest viagra

  290. Pingback: viagra online cheap

  291. Pingback: cialis 20 mg tablet

  292. Pingback: order cialis online

  293. Pingback: cialis 20 mg online

  294. Pingback: how can i buy cialis

  295. Pingback: cialis tadalafil 20 mg tablets

  296. Pingback: viagra online generic

  297. Pingback: where to buy cialis

  298. Pingback: buying generic viagra online

  299. Pingback: viagra prescription nz

  300. Pingback: sildenafil 100mg uk cheapest

  301. Pingback: amoxicillin medicine use

  302. Pingback: tadalafil 40 mg

  303. Pingback: viagraherse

  304. Pingback: viagra prices

  305. Pingback: where do i get cialis

  306. Pingback: prednisone 40 mg cost

  307. Pingback: cheap viagra online canadian pharmacy

  308. Pingback: cialis genuine buy

  309. Pingback: is ivermectin used to treat scabies

  310. Pingback: 100mg viagra cost

  311. Pingback: best online viagra

  312. Pingback: cialis 80mg online

  313. Pingback: price of viagra

  314. Pingback: ivermectin and rosacea

  315. Pingback: stromectol 400 mg for dogs

  316. Pingback: ordering zithramax online

  317. Pingback: sildenafil 100 mg tablet

  318. Pingback: ventolin inhaler bnf

  319. Pingback: 100mg viagra lowest price

  320. Pingback: viagra spray for female in india

  321. Pingback: viagra online australia no prescription

  322. Pingback: cialis goodrx

  323. Pingback: tadalafil mexico

  324. Pingback: discount zithromax

  325. Pingback: where can you buy viagra over the counter in canada

Comments are closed.